A small but vocal group of Canadians is pushing for their country to become the 51st state of the United States, citing economic and political grievances. However, recent polls suggest that the overwhelming majority of Canadians reject the idea.
Support for US Statehood Remains Low
According to a January survey by the Angus Reid Institute, only 10% of Canadians support the idea of US statehood, while 90% oppose it outright. Advocates argue that merging with the United States could provide greater economic opportunities and lower taxes. However, economists and political analysts warn of significant economic and political risks.
The debate resurfaced after former US President Donald Trump, during a December meeting with Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, made remarks about Canada joining the US. Though initially perceived as a joke, Trump’s comments, coupled with trade tensions and US tariffs on Canadian goods, have fueled discussions among fringe groups.
Strongest Support Found in Western Provinces
The push for US statehood is most prominent in Alberta and Saskatchewan, where dissatisfaction with federal policies runs high. In Bowden, Alberta, a controversial billboard featuring Alberta Premier Danielle Smith and Donald Trump with the message “Let’s join the USA!” has drawn attention. Premier Smith, however, dismissed the notion, stating there is “no enthusiasm” for the idea.
Ryan Hemsley, a Victoria resident and proponent of US statehood, believes that joining the US would lead to better job opportunities and lower taxes. “I know that just based on my work ethic, I would be able to make more money,” he said. Other supporters cite grievances with vaccine mandates, the British monarchy, and Canada’s healthcare system.
Economic Experts Dispute Benefits of Annexation
Despite claims that joining the US would bring economic prosperity, experts refute the idea. Jim Stanford, an economist with the Centre for Future Work, argues that Canadian workers generally earn more and face fewer out-of-pocket healthcare expenses than their American counterparts.
“Americans don’t get paid in per capita GDP; they get paid in wages,” Stanford said. “The idea that Americans have access to more opportunity that Canadians are denied is absolutely false.”
A separate Ipsos poll revealed that 30% of Canadians would consider joining the US if guaranteed citizenship and asset conversion to US dollars. However, analysts point out that opinions often shift once the broader implications of annexation are considered.
Movement Lacks Political Support
Despite gaining attention in US conservative media, political analysts assert that the movement remains marginal. “No major policy initiative, let alone annexation, is going to happen unless mainstream political leaders support it, and they don’t,” said Jared Wesley, a political scientist at the University of Alberta.
While dissatisfaction with Canadian leadership persists in some regions, the idea of statehood remains a fringe issue. As debates continue, experts emphasize the economic and political stability Canada currently enjoys as an independent nation.
For more in-depth coverage on political developments, visit Coleman News.
